Gary signed for Leicester City in August 1985. His skilful passing in the midfield and confidence soon earned him praise from the manager and fans alike.
He adapted well to First Division football, but unfortunately, the side was unable to stave off relegation. However, over the following three seasons Gary came to be recognised as one of the best players in the Second Division. In fact, he was named in the Second Division PFA Team of the Year in both 1988-89 and 1989-90. As a result, he was frequently the subject of speculation with regards to the transfer market.
In 1990 Gary moved to Leeds where he replaced Vinnie Jones who had left for Sheffield United. During his first season with the side, Gary experienced a successful period when Leeds reached the semi-finals of the League Cup. He formed a strong midfield quartet with fellow Scot Gordon Strachan, and David Batty and Gary Speed. This midfield was instrumental in the success of the 1991 – 92 season, in which Leeds United have crowned League Champions.
Gary McAllister left Leeds for midlands side Coventry City in 1996 for a fee of three million pounds. This was considered to be a large sum for a player of his age. He remained with the club for four seasons and played initially under Ron Atkinson and then former Leeds teammate Gordon Strachan. He spent four years with the club before making a surprise move to Liverpool.
He played an important role in the team that won a treble of cups in the 2000 – 2001 season. He continued to demonstrate a great deal of skill, particularly with set pieces. In the 2001 UEFA Cup Final, Gary received the honour of being voted man of the match after he was directly involved in four of Liverpool’s five goals.
Gary left Liverpool at the end of the 2001-02 season to rejoin Coventry City as player-manager.
Gary McAllister is considered to be one of Liverpool’s most successful players and reached number thirty-two in the ‘100 Players Who Shook The Kop’ list in 2006.